I'm so sorry to hear that you were left feeling disappointed after trying out your Shampoo B formulation! While these recipes were created to be as universal as possible, you may find you need to tweak the ingredients to suit your hair! Shampoo B is more suited for dry scalps so if your hair is more on the oily side, we'd recommend trying the formulation of shampoo A. Also, we do generally recommend following this shampoo with a conditioner as it is very gentle and natural! Hope this helps! ?